Manufactured Vs Modular

Understanding the Key Differences Between HUD and IRC Construction Standards for Manufactured and Modular Homes

When it comes to the world of prefab homes, there are two primary codes that dictate how homes are built: HUD (Housing and Urban Development) standards and IRC (International Residential Code) standards. Although both types of homes are factory-built and designed for durability, they follow different sets of regulations and building standards. In this post, we’ll explore five critical differences between manufactured homes (built to HUD standards) and modular homes (built to IRC standards), so you can better understand what sets them apart.

1. Foundation Design and Support

The foundation is one of the most important structural elements of any home, and the difference in how manufactured and modular homes are supported is significant.

  • Manufactured Homes (HUD): These homes are built with a chassis and typically arrive at the site with the chassis still attached. The chassis runs down the center of the home to provide support. After delivery, the home is placed on a permanent foundation, but the chassis remains as part of the long-term structure.
  • Modular Homes (IRC): Modular homes, on the other hand, are designed to be placed directly on a permanent foundation. No chassis is used. Instead, a more robust structural system is employed, with the foundation designed to support the heavier weight of a modular home and provide added stability, especially for larger designs.

In terms of materials, modular homes use larger structural beams like 2x10s or laminated veneer lumber (LVL) for added rigidity, while manufactured homes often use smaller, lighter materials like 2x6s.

2. Wall Construction: Material and Spacing Differences

When it comes to the materials and techniques used for wall construction, both HUD and IRC codes have specific guidelines.

  • Manufactured Homes (HUD): Manufactured homes often use 2×4 framing for the interior walls, with a wider spacing of 24 inches on center. This construction is designed to minimize waste and streamline the production process, as manufactured homes are built quickly in a controlled factory setting. The exterior walls may also use thinner materials to reduce costs and keep the weight manageable for transport.
  • Modular Homes (IRC): In contrast, modular homes are built to the more rigorous IRC standards, which require 2×6 framing for exterior walls, and a 2×4 top and bottom plate. The interior walls are generally framed with 2x4s and spaced 16 inches on center for better structural integrity. This results in a sturdier, more durable wall system for the long term.

3. Roof Design and Load Specifications

Roofing is another area where manufactured and modular homes differ significantly.

  • Manufactured Homes (HUD): These homes tend to have flatter roofs with a gentle slope due to their transportation needs. The design of the roof also accommodates the 30-pound snow load, which is typical in areas with mild winter climates. Manufactured homes usually use trusses with a 5:12 pitch.
  • Modular Homes (IRC): Modular homes, by contrast, have more flexibility in roof design. They can feature steeper pitches, and the roof system is often built with higher load-bearing capacity to meet the snow load requirements of specific areas. Depending on local codes, modular roofs can be designed for snow loads ranging from 30 pounds to as high as 100 pounds per square foot, ensuring they can withstand more extreme weather conditions.

4. Insulation: Efficiency and Comfort

Energy efficiency is another key difference between manufactured and modular homes, particularly when it comes to insulation.

  • Manufactured Homes (HUD): These homes typically use R-13 to R-19 insulation in the exterior walls, with some models offering up to R-21. The floor insulation often uses large pillowing blankets of R-38, and the ceiling insulation is generally R-38 as well. While this is effective, it may not always meet the most stringent energy efficiency standards.
  • Modular Homes (IRC): Under the IRC, modular homes are required to meet higher standards, including R-21 insulation in the walls (typically achieved using 2×6 framing). In the floors, the insulation standard is R-30, and the ceiling often features R-49 insulation to provide better thermal protection. This higher level of insulation ensures better energy efficiency, particularly in regions with extreme climates.

5. Electrical and Energy Efficiency

The way homes are designed to handle electricity, lighting, and heating/cooling systems varies significantly between manufactured and modular homes.

  • Manufactured Homes (HUD): Manufactured homes still often rely on outdated incandescent lighting, which is less energy-efficient compared to modern lighting options. HVAC systems are also built to older standards, which may not be as efficient in terms of energy consumption.
  • Modular Homes (IRC): In contrast, modular homes built to IRC standards are required to use energy-efficient LED lighting (at least 75% of the home’s lighting), and many modular homes are designed with energy-saving features like Energy Star-rated appliances and high-efficiency HVAC systems. In fact, some modular home manufacturers go above and beyond by using 100% LED lighting and adding spray foam insulation to improve both comfort and energy savings. Modular homes are also typically built with ERV (Energy Recovery Ventilation) systems to improve air quality while conserving energy.

Conclusion: Which is Right for You?

Whether you choose a manufactured home or a modular home depends on your specific needs and location. Manufactured homes are typically more affordable and faster to build, but they follow less stringent building codes and may not offer the same level of durability and energy efficiency as modular homes, which are built to meet higher standards and can provide better long-term value, especially in harsh climates.

Before deciding, it’s important to consider factors like local building codes, climate, energy efficiency needs, and budget. If you’re looking for a home that can handle more extreme weather conditions and provide better insulation and energy efficiency, modular homes built to IRC standards are likely the better option.

For more detailed information on modular homes and factory-built homes, including topics like HVAC systems and energy efficiency, be sure to check out our other videos and blog posts.

Let us know in the comments if you’d like us to dive deeper into any of these topics, and don’t forget to subscribe to stay updated on all things related to modular homes, tiny homes, and prefab construction.

Free Property Evaluation